Score: 9

"Nice"

submission: Wade, I'm Coming Home

date: November 3, 2005

Without wanting (or, for that matter, being able to) to comment on the story behind it, I've got to say I very much liked the Flash itself.

Nice graphics, fitting music, and just generally very well-done.

Score: 8

"Very funny"

submission: Incredible Saga

date: November 1, 2005

Very funny, nicely animated, fitting music. :) Definitely one of my favourites for today.

Score: 7

"OK..."

submission: The Thing 2 : Vol 2

date: November 1, 2005

It was OK, but not ground-shaking. I don't usually like this graphical style, but you saved it by adding details like hair, mouths etc. that set it apart from similar movies; as for the music, it was quite nice, but ended before the movie did.

Still, not bad at all. Keep it up.

Score: 6

"'twas OK"

submission: Dead Stench 1

date: November 1, 2005

It was OK, if a bit scary for my taste. :) Good graphics and voices, definitely.

A minor nitpick: chloroform etc. don't actually work nearly as fast as you showed in real life, although considering they often do in other (Hollywood) movies as well, it's not a surprise that you got that wrong. :) It's a pretty common misconception.

Score: 9

"Wow."

submission: The Good and The Evil

date: November 1, 2005

Wow. Sweet. :) And the fact that it had Sigur Rós music (which also fits perfectly) just makes it even better. ^^

Score: 8

"Nice"

submission: The Future (5SOP)

date: October 28, 2005

I'm not sure what the previous reviewer was smoking, but Newgrounds is most certainly not a site for 2D animations only. It's true that animations that don't utilise Flash but rather just use it as a container format for a "regular" movie are somewhat frowned upon, but this doesn't have to do anything with whether the contents is 2D or 3D or 38DD. :)

I actually rather like 3D graphics, myself; the reason why I'm only giving you an eight there is that you're overusing reflectiveness, IMO. I do realise it might be intentional, supposed to create an otherworld-ly effect, but it was somewhat distracting.

The eight for sound is ten for a good song, minus two for an audible loss of quality.

All in all, do keep it up.

Score: 8

"Nice"

submission: Black Mages 5

date: October 22, 2005

Very nice, and it's quite interesting to see how much you improved over the course of the series, too. There are still some weak points in your animation, but they're very minor, and I think that the frontpage and daily feature are both well-deserved.

Looking forward to Black Mages 6!

Score: 7

"Nice"

submission: How to draw Salad Fingers

date: October 15, 2005

Nice. The only thing that was somewhat irritating was the ton of spelling mistakes. :) But that's really just a minor thing.

Score: 4

"Doesn't work"

submission: Trampoline Gadget v.35

date: October 15, 2005

Doesn't work - most of the time, the mouse pointer just goes over the trampoline without hitting it (that is, without the trampoline recognising that it's been hit). And yes, I do have Flashplayer 8 installed, so that's not the problem.

Score: 7

"Cute"

submission: KO Boxing

date: October 6, 2005

Very cute. :) The animation's nice and clean, too, and I like the idea, too. ^_~ The only thing that's definitely missing is sound effects - punching, blocking, heavy breathing, humping, moaning and all that.

Still, it's one of the best submissions I've seen so far today, and I do hope you'll make an updated version with sound effects added. :)